Author: Rafe Martin
Illustrator: David Shannon
Publisher: G.P.Putnam’s Sons, 1992
Age: 5-9
Themes: Algonquin Indians, Cinderella
Opening: Once, long ago, there was a village by the shores of Lake Ontario.
Summary: (from my library catalog) In this Algonquin Indian version of the Cinderella story, the Rough-Face Girl and her two beautiful but heartless sisters compete for the affections of the Invisible Being.
Why I like this book: After reading a collection of tales illustrated by Edmund Dulac, and being interested in the Cinderella illustration (see below), I sought out other versions, and wanted to share two of the most stunning I found.
Author: Ai-Ling Louie
Illustrator: Ed Young
Publisher: Philomel, 1982
Age: 5-9
Themes: Chinese tales, Cinderella, Stepchildren
Opening: Once, long ago, there was a village by the shores of Lake Ontario.
Summary: (from my library catalog) This version of the Cinderella story, in which a young girl overcomes the wickedness of her stepsister and stepmother to become the bride of a prince, is based on ancient Chinese manuscripts written 1000 years before the earliest European version.
Resources/Activities: Find more versions, of this tale and others. Compare and contrast what you like, or don’t like, about each one.
For more Perfect Picture Book picks with teacher/parent resources, check out the list on Susanna Hill’s blog HERE.
I have both of these (and MORE Cinderella stories from around the world! 🙂 ) Classroom favorites and fun to see the cultural differences with traditional tales.
LikeLike
I’m familiar with both these stories, too. Good choices!
LikeLike
My daughter was reading over my shoulder and says she loved THE ROUGH-FACE GIRL. I’ve never read either of these so I’ll have to check them out! Gorgeous illustrations!
LikeLike
I knew the first one but not the second. Great suggestions to pair with more modern versions in the classroom.
LikeLike
Actually think it’s a great activity that shows kids it’s more than okay to have your own opinions!
LikeLike
Interesting versions of the Cinderella tale. Who knew there was a Chinese one that predated the European one? Thanks for letting me know.
LikeLike
Oh Wow! I’ve not seen these stories. How incredible the Chinese version was written 1000 years before the European version. Both have beautiful illustrations. Thanks for sharing Julie.
LikeLike
I remember reading these to my kids, and we started looking for as many Cinderella stories as we could. It’s fun to see how similar tales are told around the world.
LikeLike
Makes it easier for kids to see how small the big world can be!
LikeLike
What treasures. Is it possible that the basis for the Cinderella story did come from China? I love the different and unusual retellings. Great choices!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Maybe!
LikeLike
Pingback: Kid’s Review: Yeh-Shen by Ai-Ling Louie – Old Firehouse Books
Pingback: Kid’s Review: The Rough-Face Girl by Rafe Martin and David Shannon – Old Firehouse Books